“Thunderbolts*” is strictly MCU busywork
Trending
Why is there an asterisk in the title? It's dumb, and you'll have to sit through the entire end credits for some eye-rolling extra scenes to know why it's there. "Superman," please come soon and save our summer movie season.
We're going on year 16 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the franchise's initial smooth sailing has now become consistently turbulent. The last time I was truly moved and enthralled by these movies, they were "Black Panther: Wakanda Forever," "Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings" and "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3." That sounds like a solid triple, except there have been so many awful movies, Disney+ series, spinoffs and stand-alone minis before, after and in-between.
I was at San Diego Comic Con in 2008 when Jon Favreau took the stage and showed an ecstatic crowd an abbreviated cut of the first act of "Iron Man." We knew it was going to be great because the footage was all character, little spectacle, with only a fleeting f/x shot presented of Tony Stark in his flying suit. Clearly, this was popcorn cinema at the event level.
Watching "Thunderbolts*," I had the same sinking feeling when I saw "Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness," which was, A) this movie has no original concepts, only reminders of everything that came before it; B) this only works for the fanbase, as newcomers will be lost in the weeds; and C) I hope there won't be test when it's over.
Here, supporting characters from major MCU films, led by Florence Pugh's Yelena, David Harbour's Red Guardian and Sebastian Stan's Bucky Barnes, among others, team up to face Valentina de Fontaine, a super villain played by Julia Louis-Dreyfus.
The opening shot is a stunner, and the film never tops it. Instead, we have too many scenes of characters stuck in a room, bickering endlessly. The amount of profanity and violence makes this unsuitable for kids, who will probably see it anyway.
"Thunderbolts*" amounts to a lot of busywork, the equivalent of a flurry of commercials intended to distract fans waiting for the next big thing to arrive. Audience goodwill will go a long way to excusing how dreary, visually ugly and repetitive it is.
Speaking of audience goodwill, can we all be adults about this and admit that Louis- Dreyfuss, a talented and accomplished actress, is absurdly miscast and creates zero tension as the central villain? I felt more genuine danger from Louis-Dreyfus when Elaine attempted to dance at that J. Peterman Party. Honestly, the Soup Nazi would be a better villain.
Being self-aware doesn't give the movie a bulletproof vest, as the characters declare that "we're losers," "we suck," "it's all about marketing" and "the online reaction was negative." Just because the dialog addresses what we're thinking, that doesn't excuse this from being second rate.
The best moments are redone bits from other movies, like the highway shootout that's out of "Terminator Salvation," the evaporating people borrowed from "War of the Worlds" and, an especially bizarre misstep, one of the main bad guys is dressed exactly like Nuclear Man from "Superman IV: The Quest for Peace." When you blatantly resort to stealing from the fourth Terminator and Superman installments, it's clear something went wrong.
Perhaps the best thing here is a no-joke attempt to explore what it feels like to be plagued with depression and how, individually and with a support system, one can fight it. I don't think the movie is especially deep about this topic; in fact, the very-early Marvel entry, Ang Lee's "Hulk" explored this with far more depth and emotional richness (by the way, that wonky art film is so much better than most remember). Nevertheless, if "Thunderbolts*" helps even one person deal with crippling depression, that alone makes seeing it once worthwhile.
Also in the plus category are Pugh and Harbour, both burdened with busy Russian accents -- strangely, their characters never speak Russian to one another when they're alone. Although I grew tired of their Boris and Natasha schtick, Pugh and Harbour give the most passionate acting turns and created the only characters I truly cared about.
Although the film is boldly exploring the effects of depression on superheroes, that doesn't mean the film had to resemble an overcast Zac Snyder movie, as it's been filmed with a washed out grey. There are worse MCU movies, but this one's also an eyesore.
(2 out of 4 stars)
Barry Wurst II is the founder of the Hawaii Film Critics Society and teaches film classes at University of Hawai'i Maui College.