Breaking News
Free

Maui voters approve 6 of 8 County Charter amendments; narrow defeat keeps Independent Nomination Board in place

By Allyson Whaley 4 min read

Maui County voters approved six of eight proposed amendments to the County Charter in the Nov. 3 general election, weighing changes to government oversight, public participation and administrative procedures.

The eight proposed amendments addressed several aspects of county government, including the responsibilities of planning commissions, the processing of public petitions, emergency funding and the appointment of government officials.

Voters rejected two measures. Question 5 proposed removing the English translation of the state motto from the Maui County Charter's preamble, and Question 7 sought to repeal the charter provisions establishing the county's Independent Nomination Board and return nomination and appointment authority to the mayor and County Council. Both failed.

Question 5 would have removed the English translation of the state motto, "The life of the land is perpetuated in righteousness," from the charter's preamble while retaining the Hawaiian language, "Ua mau ke ea o ka ʻāina i ka pono." The proposal centered on how the motto's meaning is represented in English, with proponents arguing that the translation does not fully convey its meaning in Hawaiian.

Question 7 was narrowly defeated, with 20,906 votes against and 20,643 in favor -- a margin of 263 votes.

The remaining six amendments passed, receiving support from between 54.2% and 72.5% of all ballots cast, according to the final election results.

Among the approved measures, Question 1 received the highest level of support, with 72.5% of ballots cast in favor. The amendment concerns Planning Commission review of certain proposed changes to the county's General Plan and land-use ordinances.

Question 2, which addresses the review periods for voter initiatives, recalls and charter amendments, passed with 71.2% support. Question 3, concerning how deadlines are calculated under the County Charter, received 62.4% of ballots cast in favor.

Voters also approved Question 4, which changes the process for filing claims against the county, with 68.3% support. Question 6, concerning emergency appropriations, passed with 60.1% of ballots cast in favor.

Question 8, which allows members of the Board of Ethics to be reappointed for one successive term, passed with 54.2% of ballots cast in favor -- the lowest percentage among the six approved amendments.

Question 7 focused on the Independent Nomination Board, which was established through a 2022 charter amendment intended to make appointments to county boards and commissions more transparent and less politically influenced.

Previously, the mayor nominated candidates for the positions, subject to confirmation by the Maui County Council. An amendment created the independent panel responsible for recruiting, evaluating and recommending candidates, giving community members a greater role in the appointment process.

But the board has struggled to maintain a quorum, limiting its ability to complete the nomination process and submit recommendations for county appointments.

The board's challenges have already affected appointments for the next county term.

Following the Sept. 8 resignation of board Chair Dwight Burns and a member's recusal from the attorney-selection process, the Independent Nomination Board lacked enough eligible members to formally act on recommendations for corporation counsel and prosecuting attorney.

Under the charter's fallback procedure, Maui County Mayor Richard Bissen submitted his own nominees for the positions. The outgoing County Council voted unanimously Friday to confirm Mimi Desjardins as corporation counsel and Andrew Martin as prosecuting attorney. Both appointments are set to take effect Jan. 2, 2027.

Managing Director Josiah Nishita explained why the Independent Nomination Board was unable to submit its recommendations during the Nov. 12 meeting of the Council's Government Relations, Ethics and Transparency Committee.

"Unfortunately, before the nominations were able to be forwarded on and adopted by the Independent Nomination Board, there was a resignation by one of its members. And because of another member having to recuse themselves from the vote, they didn't have enough individuals to take a formal action on that. So the Independent Nomination Board was not able to forward on their recommendation to the mayor, and hence they didn't meet their deadline to take action," Nishita said.

The county's website lists five of the board's nine positions as filled, leaving four vacancies. Board members are appointed by the mayor with the County Council's approval to serve staggered five-year terms.

With voters rejecting the proposed repeal, the Independent Nomination Board will remain part of Maui County's appointment process. Maintaining enough eligible members to review candidates and make formal recommendations could remain a challenge during the next county term.

Allyson Whaley is reporting for The Maui News as part of the Maui Nui Media and Creativity Collaborative Investigative Elections Reporting Fellowship, which supports expanded reporting on Maui County elections.

Starting at /week.