Breaking News
Letters to the Editor

Letter: Independent Nomination Board fiasco explained

By Dave DeLeon 2 min read

There are reasons for failure in the ongoing Independent Nomination Board fiasco.

The INB was proposed and adopted into the County Charter by county voters in 2022.

It was originally intended to support the recruitment of applicants for the county's 30-plus boards, commissions and official advisory panels, based on a model Mayor Alan Arakawa created in his first term.

But despite this good intention, the Bissen Administration failed to even try to use this board to improve recruitment.

The 2022 Charter Commission decided as its last act before putting INB before the voters, to make this board also a pre-screening committee for the appointments of the Corporation Counsel, Prosecuting Attorney, County Clerk and the County Auditor.

Consequently, Maui County Council correctly asked the voters in the last election to eliminate this board, but seriously failed to adequately explain why, and even failed to give any notice that it was bringing eight proposed charter amendments, what they were and why they were proposed.

For the county administration to find applicants for numerous posts from sparsely populated districts -- especially Molokai, Lanai, and Hana -- was and always will be a struggle.

The problem with this approach is that it was ad hoc, not based on a law or the charter. The 2022 charter codified it, but the Bissen Administration did not demonstrate any interest in applicant recruitment until it was well behind the curve.

The INB has no requirement for any kind of professional qualification: how could it adequately review and make recommendations? And worse yet, the timing of the board's required action puts these appointments in the hands of the out-going mayor and council and not the newly elected leaders.

Dave DeLeon
Ha'ikū

Starting at /week.